- Iacobucci
- Iames
- Iannelli
- Ibanez
- Ibbotson
- Ice
- Icenhower
- Icenogle
- Icsman
- Iden
- Idselies
- Iezzoni
- Ignatius
- Igoe
- Ihle
- Ihlendorf
- Iker
- Iles
- Ilhardt
- Ille
- Illig
- Illing
- Imas
- Imbronyev
- Imbus
- Imfeld
- Imhoff
- Imholte
- Imhulse
- Imm
- Immerman
- Imwalle
- Inderhees
- Infante
- Ingguls
- Ingle
- Inglert
- Ingmire
- Ingram
- Inkrot
- Inlow
- Inman
- Innes
- Inskeep
- Ionna
- Ipox
- Ipp
- Iredale
- Ireland
- Irey
- Irimes
- Irvin
- Isaac
- Isaack
- Isaacs
- Isakson
- Isekeit
- Iseman
- Isenberg
- Isidor
- Iskra
- Isler
- Isphording
- Itkoff
- Itzkowitz
- Ivers
- Ivester
- Ivey
- Ivins
- Ivory
- Iwema